@rastaman289
Free roaming.
That's why there's still an enemy threat.
As in SaintsRowIV you still have alien threats
As in SaintsRowThe3rd you have the random emergency calls.
In both you have player invasion
Co-op replayable activities
Co-op allowing friendly fire
Multiplayer is nice but unfortunately that's become a selling point for many strong single player games such as this & to me multiplayer makes single player pointless.
Why put in the effort on single player when so many rather play multiplayer.
Ask around, what gets more replay in GTAV
Single or multi
DeadSpace2 added multiplayer & it nearly killed single player to me.
DeadSpace2 multiplayer took away the element of surprise
Allowed weapon training
Strategy building
Familiarity with character movement.
DeadSpace2's multiplayer took away alot of single player campaign's challenge.
Volition puts alot of effort into characters, stories, etc.
Single player should get all the replay value not multiplayer where gamers could spend time.
Depend on the game design, bro.
As you can see, GTAV has its multiplayer mode separated from the single, unlike SR and Borderlands. GTA Online is a whole separate game that makes GTAV as if a big 2-weeks tutorial for the Online mode. Rockstar also wants you to play GTA O and they also support Online mode 1000x more than the single player.
I agree that Single Player needs to be sharpened and we shouldn't too much relying to Online. Take example, what if ISP is down at the moment and it's your chill time? I wouldn't touch GTAV and Borderlands, to be honest. I would pick my Dynasty Warriors over those games when there's internet outage (let's say I didn't have SR in this case).
Why? Because in Dynasty Warriors there is 'O B J E C T I V E' in single player which makes my gameplay has a 'backbone' and doing objective will give me random reward, although the game's been finished. This is the same as SR3 Survival (especially) and SR4 challenges.
While in Borderlands, when you've done with the playthrough, you're basically in the world walking aimlessly or have a single objective to do, "Kill Raid Boss" - over and over again. Yep, without the existence of other players, Borderlands is drought land - to me, at least.
TL;DR: Objective is needed to make Single Player has its 'replay value'